Examining media choices related to the development of online learning resources
In looking at the emerging new media technologies that have transformed the way we communicate, and how we interact with one another, we can begin to see the advantages and disadvantages of each new media. As designers and instructors of online learning courses, it is our responsibility to utilize new media technologies in such a way as to get the greatest impact, as well offer the best interaction for our students. Dr. Newberry, in his article called “Media Richness, Social Presence and Technology Supported Communication Activities in Education,” designed a table that evaluates how each media rates as far as media richness. He goes as far as creating a hierarchal structure that rates each media from low to high as far as its’ effectiveness, media richness, and social presence and interaction. It is this model, or rubric if you will, that I rate my own experiences with new media technologies.
Media Rating (across)
Criteria(down) |
High |
Medium |
Low |
Feedback |
Face to Face
Video Conferencing
Synchronous Audio
Text Based Chat |
|
E-mail
Threaded Discussion
Asynchronous Audio |
Multiple cues |
Face to Face |
Video Conferencing |
Synchronous Audio
Asynchronous Audio
Text Based Chat
E-mail
Threaded Discussion |
Message Tailoring |
Face to Face |
Video Conferencing
Synchronous Audio
E-mail |
Text Based Chat
Asynchronous Audio
Threaded Discussion |
Emotions |
Face to Face |
Video Conferencing
Synchronous Audio
Asynchronous Audio |
Text Based Chat
E-mail
Threaded Discussion |
Table from: Newberry. (2001). Raising Student Social Presence In Online Classes. WebNet 2001 Proceedings (In Press)
By assigning the numerical value of 3 for high, 2, for medium and 1 for low, Newberry (2001) ranked the seven different media types into a hierarchy from richest to leanest media. Rich media are media that carry the most information; lean media carries the least information.
Face – to – Face
Video Conferencing
Synchronous Audio
Text – Based Chat
E-mail / Asynchronous Audio
Threaded Discussion
Table from: Newberry. (2001). Raising Student Social Presence In Online Classes. WebNet 2001 Proceedings (In Press)
1. Streaming Media
My first experience with streaming media was when I participated in the Jason Project and Immersion Presents, created by Dr. Robert Ballard, and collaborated by countless other scientists and educational institutions. I actually participated in two different projects. The first being the rainforest in Panama, and the second being the Monterey Bay. We actually got to take groups of students to the CSU Palm Desert campus where students could watch streaming video of students and scientists participating in science related experiments. In addition, selected students were chosen to ask questions of the scientists. The kid’s questions were digitally recorded and then relayed to the scientists via live streaming to the scientist. In addition, I’ve also participated in a program called PORTS(Parks Online Resources for Teachers and Students) run by the California State Parks. California State Parks PORTS program provides teachers and students with complete units of study and live videoconferences. We just recently did a videoconference on the gold rush up in an old mining town called Columbia which is now a historic state park. We plan to do another one in January on tide pools at Crystal Cove State Park where we will be learning about tide pool ecology and about ocean habitats. The advantage of live streaming video is that students get to interact with the ranger giving the presentation. The downside is that our technology department has to set up the equipment. It also requires scheduling the presentation, which can sometimes lead to scheduling conflicts. Another area where I have accessed streaming media is through Discovery Education’s United Streaming. This is often where I would go to find videos, photos, teacher’s guides, and worksheets on things that we were learning in the classroom. Often you could store these resources in folders for easy access. Another advantage is that you could access video segments that allowed you to show small parts of a video that were pertinent to the lesson and fit in the time frame. The disadvantage of United Streaming is that it is expensive, and so your school needs to be willing to pay for it. In fact we have since dropped United Streaming for a program called Learning 360 which is simililar. I have used it, but I find that it still has limited resources. I much prefer United Streaming. Presently, I do not plan to use streaming media as tool to train teachers on how to setup a parent page at their school site. It is not totally out of the question, but it’s not something I’m considering right now. Also, students have limited access to these resources except at school. Though streaming media is media rich, and is a great way to engage students the equipment to do it can be rather expensive.
2. Podcast
My first experience with podcasting was through the ETEC program. In a number of my online courses Dr. Newberry and Dr. Baek have often relied on audio or video podcasts to deliver information relevant to the course and the assignments. I later took a podcasting workshop at the district technology department where I learned about the different types of podcasting. One of the ways to do a podcast was through a program called Photostory 3 which was way of taking photographs, audio, music and put them together in a slide presentation format. Perhaps the best advantage of a podcast, such as an audio podcast is that it can be downloaded, replayed and even loaded onto your iPod or mp3 player. These devices are mobile so you can listen to the podcast just about anywhere. The only drawback that I see is that it is low on the rich media scale therefore limiting interaction with the instructor and other students.
3. Forums/Bulletin Boards
I have experienced the use of forums before through the ETEC program but on a limited scale. The advantages of a discussion forum is that students are allowed , to post comments, hyperlinks to assigned readings, and any individual questions they might have regarding assignments, generating a good flow of information that can be shared with the whole class and instructor. The disadvantage of discussion forums is that some people communicate better, and can better express their ideas important issues, leaving others somewhat intimidated at times. I have no real experience using bulletin boards on the computer.
4. Threaded Discussion
I have been actively involved in a number of threaded discussions throughout the ETEC program. For me they were very informative and insightful. I would tend to agree with Dr. Newberry’s observations, in that the threaded discussions could often become very confusing when the discussion branches off into so many different directions that you often lose sight of the original train of thought. What I like about the threaded discussion is that it allows everyone to be respond to the question(s) generated by the instructor, and to and allows them to respond to each other’s comments. It’s also asynchronous so you are not having to answer right away. The downside of this is much like the discussion forum is that often people can be opinionated or biased about a particular topic. Sometimes this has an adverse effect and slants the discussion in a certain way.
5. Skype/Talkshoe/Dim Dim
Throughout the ETEC program I have had experience with Skype, Talkshoe and Dim Dim which are all VOIP programs. The program that I am most familiar with is Skpe. It rates well as far as media richness and social presence, but it has limitations on the amount of people that can be conferencing at one time. I remember getting booted off on several occasions. I also used Skype to talk to my girlfriend in England as she was studying Shakespeare in London. Most recently I experienced using Talkshoe with both Dr. Newberry and Dr. Baek. I found it to be a little more user friendly. Dr. Baek also introduced us to Dim Dim. It’s a nice program but it can be costly. I will more than likely be using Talkshoe for my course although I’m not sure of the cost factor. I do know that Skype is presently free which could be an advantage.
6. Chat/Instant Messaging
I haven’t really used chatting or instant messaging in an educational setting or for purposes of using it in my online course. I have used it to some extent using VOIP programs such as Skype and Talkshoe. I never felt that I was being heard in those chat settings. They became very much like threaded discussions at times, and I would often lose track of the thought process, because chatting often calls for thinking fast on your feet. I primarily use chatting in a social network framework where I can keep in touch with family and friends. I am currently using Facebook. I often text message or chat with Kathy on Facebook about the assignment, or scheduling time to study and work on the assignments. I will admit that I am limited to the amount of chatting only because I am not great at multitasking, and find myself focusing on one thing. Chatting is in the middle when it comes to media richness, and this may be in part to the amount of interaction that is taking place. I think that there is a certain amount of social presence that is felt when communicating through chatting
Teacher Tube/You Tube.
Websites like You Tube and Teacher Tube are sites specifically designed to share media. As Dr. Newberry stated in his podcast, “You Tube permits users to easily upload video search for videos, and in many cases comment upon videos. It is perhaps the comment feature that makes you tube a Web 2.o application that is harnessing the power of social networking to promote videos.” I would tend to agree. There are some excellent videos on You Tube. Unfortunately, our district blocks You Tube access making it very frustrating to use it. I have a Teacher Tube account and have accessed videos that our educationally suitable for my classroom. Many of the videos I use teach certain skills within the curriculum. They are suitable videos that can be engaging for students.
Second Life
I have no previous experience with Second Life. I don’t see any viable reason for using Second Life in my online course. Because this virtual environment is much like an online game, I don’t think it is suited for the type of training or teaching I will be conducting in this course. It may eventually have a firm foothold in education someday, but right now I don’t see how it could help me at the elementary level.
Scenario using Web tools 2.0 & 3.0 with effective implementation of technology.
Gold Rush
What I propose to teach using Web 2.0 tools, and eventually Web 3.0 tools can be used in a number of curricular areas, but my focus here will be social studies and the gold rush. The gold rush was instrumental in perpetuating the economic growth of California, later allowing it to become a state.
Going for the Gold!
The purpose of this assignment is to learn about the California Gold Rush which took place from 1848-1859. Your assignment will be to design and create a multimedia project using Photostory 3.
The first thing you are going to do is watch a short video that I created using Photostory 3 about the California Gold Rush. Be sure to click download now to get full screen or otherwise you get a small version that may be hard to view.
http://cms.dsusd.k12.ca.us/education/components/docmgr/default.php?sectiondetailid=59579&fileitem=27188&catfilter=ALL
After viewing my video, you will be directed to a Powerpoint slide that will give you a website that will provide a video that will teach you how to use Photostory 3. This information is on the last slide of my Photostory. After viewing the video please choose one of the topics given on the PowerPoint slide to create your own Photostory 3 project. I’ve put all the information here as well.
Photostory 3 Tutorial
http://www.teachertube.com/viewVideo.php?video_id=75267
PowerPoint Slide
http://cms.dsusd.k12.ca.us/education/components/docmgr/default.php?sectiondetailid=59579&fileitem=27187&catfilter=ALL
I am really looking forward to seeing your finished Photostory projects on the California Gold Rush.
If you have any questions, or run into any problems with your project, I can be reached at robert.fleck@dsusd.us
Directions for your creating your Photostory are below.
Directions to Creating Photostory Project
1. Create new folder on desktop. Make sure you label your folder to
correspond with the project you are working on for easy access. The
folder will be a place where you can store all your photos or any
documents you will be using.
2. Research your topic on the Internet. Type all of your notes in Microsoft
Word. Also, be on the lookout for photos that you can use in your project
and store them in your folder.
3. Create a storyboard with at least 10 slides. This would include a title page
4 pictures, 4 information slides, and a bibliography.
4. If you do not already have Photostory on your computer you can
download it for free off the Internet. Now you may begin creating your
own Photostory project.
5. Remember to save your information after each slide you have created so
you don’t lose any of your work.
There will also be a rubric in which the digital stories will be assessed and graded.
http://cms.dsusd.k12.ca.us/education/components/docmgr/default.php?sectiondetailid=59579&fileitem=28274&catfilter=ALL
In addition students will have access to reading material prior to students starting Photostory projects to gain additional information about the Gold Rush.
http://cms.dsusd.k12.ca.us/education/components/docmgr/default.php?sectiondetailid=59579&fileitem=28273&catfilter=ALL
I have done similar projects with students. We even entered some of the projects in the student showcase at the CUE Conference a couple of years ago. The focus then was on the State Constitution of California, and the key events that led California to have its first constitution. Here is an example:
http://cms.dsusd.k12.ca.us/education/components/docmgr/default.php?sectiondetailid=59579&fileitem=31024&catfilter=ALL